OEM vs Aftermarket Filters
OEM and aftermarket are source designations, not quality designations. Understanding what these terms actually mean—and what they don't mean—helps make better filter sourcing decisions.
What It Is
OEM Filters
Original Equipment Manufacturer filters are sold by the equipment manufacturer under their brand name.
- • Sold through OEM dealer network
- • Carry equipment manufacturer's brand
- • Often manufactured by third parties
- • Typically highest price point
Aftermarket Filters
Aftermarket filters are produced by independent manufacturers as compatible replacements.
- • Sold through distributors, direct
- • Carry manufacturer's own brand
- • Wide range of quality levels
- • Typically lower price point
Important Distinction
Many "OEM" filters are manufactured by the same companies that sell aftermarket filters. The equipment manufacturer contracts with filter manufacturers to produce filters under the OEM brand. The physical filter may be identical to an aftermarket version with different labeling.
Why It Matters
The OEM vs aftermarket decision affects cost, availability, warranty considerations, and potentially performance. Understanding the tradeoffs enables informed decisions.
| Factor | OEM | Aftermarket |
|---|---|---|
| Price | Premium pricing (often 30-100% higher) | Competitive pricing, varies by manufacturer |
| Availability | Limited to dealer network, may have lead times | Multiple sources, often better availability |
| Quality consistency | Generally consistent, single source | Varies widely by manufacturer |
| Specifications | Meets equipment manufacturer's spec | May meet, exceed, or fall short of spec |
| Warranty perception | "Safe" choice for warranty equipment | May require specification documentation |
| Technical support | Dealer/manufacturer support | Varies by manufacturer/distributor |
Common Misconceptions
"OEM is always better quality"
OEM indicates the source, not the quality. Many aftermarket manufacturers specialize in filtration and produce filters that meet or exceed OEM specifications. Some aftermarket filters outperform OEM equivalents in dirt capacity, efficiency, or service life. Evaluate specifications, not just brand.
"Aftermarket filters void warranties"
In most jurisdictions, using aftermarket parts does not automatically void warranties. Warranty denial requires demonstrating that the aftermarket part caused the failure. Document that aftermarket filters meet OEM specifications and you have warranty protection. Magnuson-Moss Warranty Act (US) provides consumer protection here.
"OEM filters are made by the equipment manufacturer"
Equipment manufacturers rarely manufacture their own filters. They contract with filter manufacturers (often the same companies selling aftermarket filters) to produce filters under the OEM brand. The "OEM" filter may be identical to an aftermarket filter with different packaging.
"All aftermarket filters are the same"
Aftermarket quality varies dramatically. Premium aftermarket manufacturers invest in R&D, testing, and quality control. Budget manufacturers optimize for price. Treating all aftermarket as equivalent is as wrong as treating all OEM as superior. Evaluate each manufacturer independently.
When OEM Is the Right Choice
- Equipment under warranty: When warranty preservation is critical and you lack documentation for aftermarket equivalence
- Certification requirements: Applications requiring specific manufacturer certifications (aerospace, nuclear, etc.)
- Contractual obligations: Service contracts specifying OEM parts
- Risk intolerance: When the cost of potential filter-related failure exceeds savings from aftermarket
- Unknown specifications: When you cannot verify aftermarket filters meet required specifications
When Aftermarket Is the Right Choice
- Cost optimization: When verified aftermarket meets specifications at lower cost
- Availability needs: When OEM lead times are unacceptable and aftermarket is in stock
- Performance upgrade: When aftermarket offers improved specifications (higher efficiency, more dirt capacity)
- Obsolete equipment: When OEM filters are discontinued but aftermarket continues production
- Multi-brand fleets: When standardizing on one aftermarket brand simplifies inventory
How to Evaluate Aftermarket Quality
Not all aftermarket filters are equal. Use these criteria to evaluate aftermarket manufacturers:
| Evaluation Criteria | What to Look For |
|---|---|
| Published specifications | Micron rating with beta ratio, collapse rating, flow capacity, materials |
| Test data availability | ISO 16889 multi-pass test results, not just claims |
| Quality certifications | ISO 9001, industry-specific certifications |
| Industry reputation | Track record, customer references, market presence |
| Technical support | Engineering assistance, application guidance available |
| Warranty coverage | Product warranty terms and claims process |
Red Flags in Aftermarket Filters
- • No published specifications beyond dimensions
- • "Equivalent to" claims without supporting data
- • Significantly lower price than comparable aftermarket brands
- • No manufacturer identification or country of origin
- • No technical support or application guidance available
Related Topics
What is a Cross-Reference? →
How filter equivalence is determined
When Cross-References Are Not Safe →
Applications requiring extra caution
Micron Ratings Explained →
Understanding efficiency specifications
Total Cost of Ownership →
Why purchase price isn't the full story
Note: The right choice between OEM and aftermarket depends on your specific application, risk tolerance, and requirements. For critical applications or when specifications are uncertain, consult with a filtration specialist before selecting alternatives.
Call (469) 608-9877 →